Today was a special day in my church. It was our annual celebration of America which happens every year around the fourth of July. I am usually out-of-town visiting relatives so I don't usually make it to that particular service. I had forgotten how much patriotism is on display in that service.
I pulled up in the parking lot and saw red, white, and blue helium balloons and flags adorning the entrance. Walking into the auditorium there was a giant sized "Declaration of Independence" projected on the back wall behind the musicians. Red, white, and blue decorations were everywhere.
I had a seat as the music team finished the opening song. Then the music pastor (a man I'm actually quite fond of) said something that made me flinch (paraphrasing) - "Aren't we blessed by God to be living in the greatest country on earth?" He continued, "We should all thank God for blessings of being born here, when we could have been born somewhere else..." The congregation reverberated with shouts of "amen" and "yes," and "thank you lord."
Without disparaging thankfulness (which is a good thing) - I was hit by the thought that these comments raised some serious theological questions. Are there unspoken assumptions behind these sentiments?
Do American born evangelical Christians really believe that the prosperity and freedom we enjoy in America is the result of God's favor upon us? If so, does that not imply that to be born elsewhere is to not have been blessed?
I sincerely doubt that our music pastor would have put it that way if asked. But these questions seemed implicit in his comments. By-the-way, I'm not singling out my music pastor. The reality is that I have heard many well-meaning Christians say very similar things.
But these comments left me thinking:
- Is it a blessing to live in a land of freedom and plenty?
- Is it therefore a curse to live in a land of poverty and/or oppression?
- Does where we reside have anything in particular to do with God's blessing or curse?
Let's tackle number one - is it a blessing to live in a land of freedom and plenty?
In Matthew 19 verse 23 Jesus makes the following statement - "it is hard for someone who is rich to enter the kingdom of heaven." (NIV) This is following the discussion with the rich man who loved his possessions more than the call of Christ.
Logically, if wealth makes it more difficult to follow Christ, and you live in a wealthy nation (such as America), then it would seem that those in such situations were not especially blessed after all. Congratulations - you won the jackpot - born in America but your prosperity kept you from ever following Jesus. Doesn't sound like a blessing to me.
The second question - is it therefore a curse to live in a land of poverty and/or oppression? is closely related to the answer to the first question. If being rich can keep you from seeing your need for Jesus - then being poor and persecuted may actually make you more acutely aware of your need. It sounds like the opposite of what we typically think. Sounds like a blessing to me. Poverty is a blessing? I think the Beatitudes actually speak to this.
The funny thing is that the scriptures are full of paradoxes like this - when we're weak we're strong, the poor are rich, the blind will see and seeing are blind.
Which brings me to the last question - does where we reside have anything in particular to do with God's blessing or curse?
This question reminds me of the question Jesus was asked by his disciples in John 9:2 "Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents that he was born blind?" Jesus answered in verse 3 "Neither this man nor his parents sinned,...but his happened so that the works of God might be displayed in him."
The disciples demonstrated a clear theological error that continues to this day - associating the condition one finds oneself in - with approval or disapproval by God. Bad circumstances equals disapproval and curse. Good circumstances equals blessing and approval.
Jesus disabuses them of this notion.
In the disciples question you could easily substitute the words "born blind," with was "born in Haiti," or "born black," or "born into poverty."
So what about the millions of followers of Jesus who live in poverty and oppression? Are they therefore cursed by God? I imagined a Christian visiting our congregation from another nation thinking - "so I am not blessed by God because I was born somewhere else?"
The answer should be obvious. We SHOULD be thankful to God for all that he provides for us. Whether food, clothing, shelter, or freedom. But we should NOT consider these things to be superior to their opposites, hunger, nakedness, deprivation, or persecution. Thankfulness is to extend in all situations. More to the point - where you find yourself is neither an endorsement of your spirituality, nor a condemnation of it.
For the record. I am grateful to live in a free and prosperous country. As a former Marine I am proud of my time in service to the U.S. However, I recognize the danger inherent in believing that prosperity means that God approves of whatever we do as a nation.
Rome was a very prosperous nation as well - and we know how that ended.
~Truly Free